Problem 6 - An Introduction to Theories of Personality

Question

Allport argues that the healthy adult shows compassion for the considerable difficulties in living faced by all human beings, and he is highly critical of the person who feels that "he and his kind matter, no one else. His church, his family, and his nation make a safe unit, but all else is alien, dangerous, [and] to be excluded from his petty formula for survival." Do you agree or disagree? Why?

Step-by-Step Solution

Answer

The short answer will depend on each individual's opinion. It could range from agreeing with Allport's statement because it promotes empathy and universal compassion, to disagreeing because it dismisses the practical necessity for individuals to prioritize their community and loved ones.

Step 1: Understanding the Context

The first step in this discussion task is to comprehend Allport's view fully. He suggests that a healthy adult should possess compassion towards others hardships and criticizes individuals who see the world just from their and their community's perspectives, considering others as alien or a threat.

Step 2: Reflect on the Statement

Once the sentiment behind Allport's statement is clear, the next step is to form an opinion about it. This step will vary for everyone as it is largely based on personal experiences, beliefs, and values. It's crucial to think deeply about Allport's statement and your perspective on the topic.

Step 3: Formulate Argument

After forming an opinion, it's essential to articulate it compellingly. Begin by stating if you agree or disagree with Allport's perspective. Then, provide reasons for your viewpoint, citing personal experiences, studies, theories, or examples that support your stance. Try to explore diverse perspectives and remain respectful of differing opinions.

Step 4: Conclusion

Lastly, wrap up your argument with a summary sentence or two. Recap your main points and opinion in brief. This will provide closure to your argument and strengthen your standpoint.