Problem 10
Question
Five processes can foster microevolutionary change: gene flow, genetic drift, mutation, natural selection, and nonrandom mating (see Section 21.3 ). Which of those processes might contribute to the evolution of Batesian mimicry in two butterfly species? Would the same processes affect both the mimic and the model similarly? Which processes might have contributed to the evolution of the mutualistic relationship between ants and acacia trees, and how would their action on the two mutualists differ?
Step-by-Step Solution
Verified Answer
Batesian mimicry in butterflies could be a result of natural selection and mutation. Natural selection could also contribute to the mutualistic relationship between ants and acacia trees along with gene flow and genetic drift. The effect of these processes wouldn't be the same for all species involved in the interactions. For instance, in the case of mimicry, the benefits to the model are indirect, and for mutualism, natural selection would favor different traits in ants and trees.
1Step 1: Analyzing Batesian Mimicry in Butterflies
Batesian mimicry, where a harmless species mimics the warning signals of a harmful species to deter predators, could be a result of natural selection. Both the mimic and model butterflies would display similar patterns/colors, making it difficult for predators to distinguish between them. If the characteristics providing the mimicry have a genetic basis, then mutation could also play a role. Genetic drift, gene flow, and nonrandom mating might also contribute but would likely have lesser influences compared to natural selection and mutation.
2Step 2: Comparing the Effect on Mimic and Model
The effects of these processes would not be the same on both the mimic and the model. For example, if it's a case of natural selection favoring the mimic because it avoids predation, the model does not directly benefit. On the other hand, if the mimicry dilutes the predator's attention from the model species, then the model butterfly could also indirectly benefit.
3Step 3: Analyzing Mutualism Between Ants and Acacia Trees
In the mutualistic relationship between ants and acacia trees, ants protect the trees from herbivores and in return, the trees provide shelter and food for the ants. This relationship could be a result of natural selection favoring traits that enhance the survival and reproductive success of both ants and trees. Gene flow and genetic drift might also play a role. Nonrandom mating is not likely to have a significant effect here as it's more significant in mate choice scenarios.
4Step 4: Differential Action on Ants and Acacia Trees
Natural selection would act differently on the ants and the trees. For ants, natural selection would favor traits that make them more efficient at protecting trees and utilizing the resources provided by the trees. For the trees, natural selection would favor traits that make them attractive to ants, such as producing certain chemicals or providing suitable nesting sites.
Key Concepts
Batesian mimicryNatural selectionMutualismGene flowGenetic drift
Batesian mimicry
Batesian mimicry is a fascinating evolutionary strategy where a harmless species evolves to imitate the warning signals of a harmful species to ward off predators.
This clever form of deception benefits the mimic species by reducing their chances of being eaten, as predators tend to avoid species that they believe are dangerous. The key to successful Batesian mimicry is resemblance; the mimic must closely resemble the model species in coloration, pattern, or behavior.
Natural selection plays a major role in this process, as only those individuals that most closely resemble the dangerous species are more likely to survive and reproduce.
Mutations can introduce new variants or improvements in mimicry traits. While genetic drift and gene flow might have less impact here, they can still contribute by altering gene frequency or introducing new genetic material into populations.
However, the mimic and model species do not benefit equally from these evolutionary processes. Natural selection primarily favors the mimic species, although there may be indirect benefits to the model in spreading confusion among predators.
This clever form of deception benefits the mimic species by reducing their chances of being eaten, as predators tend to avoid species that they believe are dangerous. The key to successful Batesian mimicry is resemblance; the mimic must closely resemble the model species in coloration, pattern, or behavior.
Natural selection plays a major role in this process, as only those individuals that most closely resemble the dangerous species are more likely to survive and reproduce.
Mutations can introduce new variants or improvements in mimicry traits. While genetic drift and gene flow might have less impact here, they can still contribute by altering gene frequency or introducing new genetic material into populations.
However, the mimic and model species do not benefit equally from these evolutionary processes. Natural selection primarily favors the mimic species, although there may be indirect benefits to the model in spreading confusion among predators.
Natural selection
Natural selection is one of the driving forces behind evolution, including microevolutionary changes such as Batesian mimicry or mutualistic relationships.
It operates by favoring individuals that have advantageous traits, increasing their likelihood of surviving and reproducing compared to those without those traits.
This will result in a gradual increase in the frequency of these beneficial traits in the population.
In the case of Batesian mimicry, natural selection is the main process as birds or other predators learn to avoid butterflies exhibiting certain warning signals, thereby allowing mimics to thrive.
When considering mutualism, such as the relationship between ants and acacia trees, natural selection favors traits that enhance cooperation. Ants that are better at defending trees or trees that produce more attractive rewards will be favored as the mutualistic relationship strengthens their survival.
Natural selection is fundamentally about adapting to current conditions, leading to a variety of fascinating and complex interactions in the natural world.
It operates by favoring individuals that have advantageous traits, increasing their likelihood of surviving and reproducing compared to those without those traits.
This will result in a gradual increase in the frequency of these beneficial traits in the population.
In the case of Batesian mimicry, natural selection is the main process as birds or other predators learn to avoid butterflies exhibiting certain warning signals, thereby allowing mimics to thrive.
When considering mutualism, such as the relationship between ants and acacia trees, natural selection favors traits that enhance cooperation. Ants that are better at defending trees or trees that produce more attractive rewards will be favored as the mutualistic relationship strengthens their survival.
Natural selection is fundamentally about adapting to current conditions, leading to a variety of fascinating and complex interactions in the natural world.
Mutualism
Mutualism is an interaction between two different species where both parties benefit from the relationship.
This is a type of symbiotic relationship, where the mutual benefits contribute to the survival and reproductive success of both species involved.
In the classic example of ants and acacia trees, ants gain food and shelter from the trees, while the trees receive protection from herbivores courtesy of the ants.
Such relationships often form through natural selection, with traits that promote the symbiotic partnership becoming more prevalent over time.
Gene flow, introducing new genetic variations, can affect these traits beneficially, while genetic drift may have less influence as the partnership strengthens specific interdependence.
In mutualistic relationships, the interaction may impose different selection pressures on each party. For instance, the trees might evolve to enhance resources provided to the ants, while ants might evolve to be more efficient protectors.
This is a type of symbiotic relationship, where the mutual benefits contribute to the survival and reproductive success of both species involved.
In the classic example of ants and acacia trees, ants gain food and shelter from the trees, while the trees receive protection from herbivores courtesy of the ants.
Such relationships often form through natural selection, with traits that promote the symbiotic partnership becoming more prevalent over time.
Gene flow, introducing new genetic variations, can affect these traits beneficially, while genetic drift may have less influence as the partnership strengthens specific interdependence.
In mutualistic relationships, the interaction may impose different selection pressures on each party. For instance, the trees might evolve to enhance resources provided to the ants, while ants might evolve to be more efficient protectors.
Gene flow
Gene flow refers to the transfer of genetic material between populations, which can introduce new genetic variations into a population and thus contribute to microevolution.
The movement of individuals or their genetic material, through mechanisms such as migration, can lead to the exchange of genes between separated populations.
Gene flow can be beneficial by increasing genetic diversity, helping populations adapt to changing environments over time.
In the context of evolution, gene flow may lead to changes in traits such as those seen in mimicry, introducing favorable traits into a population.
For mutualistic species like ants and acacia trees, gene flow among populations might enhance traits that favor the continuation and strengthening of the mutualistic relationship.
This process prevents populations from becoming too genetically isolated, ensuring a continuous mix of traits that can be acted upon by natural selection.
The movement of individuals or their genetic material, through mechanisms such as migration, can lead to the exchange of genes between separated populations.
Gene flow can be beneficial by increasing genetic diversity, helping populations adapt to changing environments over time.
In the context of evolution, gene flow may lead to changes in traits such as those seen in mimicry, introducing favorable traits into a population.
For mutualistic species like ants and acacia trees, gene flow among populations might enhance traits that favor the continuation and strengthening of the mutualistic relationship.
This process prevents populations from becoming too genetically isolated, ensuring a continuous mix of traits that can be acted upon by natural selection.
Genetic drift
Genetic drift is a mechanism of evolution that refers to random changes in the frequency of alleles within a population.
This can occur in any population but tends to have a more pronounced effect in smaller populations. Unlike natural selection, genetic drift does not necessarily favor traits that are advantageous for survival.
Changes in allele frequencies purely by chance can lead to significant genetic variation over generations.
For example, in a small population of butterflies, purely random fluctuations might increase the frequency of an allele responsible for a particular mimicry pattern.
In mutualistic relationships, genetic drift could result in variations that either strengthen or weaken the mutualistic traits, especially if population sizes fluctuate widely.
While genetic drift can lead to diversity and novel traits, it may also lead to the loss of some beneficial alleles if those traits do not arise frequently enough to become established.
This can occur in any population but tends to have a more pronounced effect in smaller populations. Unlike natural selection, genetic drift does not necessarily favor traits that are advantageous for survival.
Changes in allele frequencies purely by chance can lead to significant genetic variation over generations.
For example, in a small population of butterflies, purely random fluctuations might increase the frequency of an allele responsible for a particular mimicry pattern.
In mutualistic relationships, genetic drift could result in variations that either strengthen or weaken the mutualistic traits, especially if population sizes fluctuate widely.
While genetic drift can lead to diversity and novel traits, it may also lead to the loss of some beneficial alleles if those traits do not arise frequently enough to become established.
Other exercises in this chapter
Problem 8
Bacteria that live in the human intestine assist digestion and feed on nutrients the human consumed. This relationship might best be described as: a. commensali
View solution Problem 9
The equilibrium theory of island biogeography predicts that the number of species found on an island: a. increases steadily until it equals the number in the ma
View solution Problem 11
The table below shows how many individuals were recorded for each of five species in five separate communities (a-e). Which community has the highest species di
View solution Problem 12
After reading about the two potential biases in the scientific literature on competition, describe how future studies of competition might avoid such biases.
View solution